1. If a panel of judges hears a case, all issues arising with respect to the hearing shall be resolved by a majority of votes. None of the judges may abstain from resolving any issue.
2. A judge who disagrees with the majority opinion at the time when a court of first instance, appeal and cassation is delivering a judgment, ruling or resolution, may present his/her dissenting opinion in writing. During the announcement of the decision, the parties to the hearing shall be notified of the existence of a dissenting opinion.
3. The dissenting opinion shall be enclosed with the case file, without disclosing its contents in a courtroom.